Which one is neville

Indeed, it's not clear the Neville had non-magical relatives to take him in. Unlike Harry, Neville would have lived his whole life in the wizarding world's spotlight. Hogwarts' friendly caretaker came into Harry's life on the night of his parents' death. This dramatic bonding experience was followed up by Dumbledore dispatching Hagrid to deliver Harry's Hogwarts letter. Hagrid met a neglected orphan and taught the boy about the wonders of wizarding England - and the truth of his family's heritage.

With no Uncle Vernon and no special reason to send Hogwarts staff to attend to Harry's enrollment, Hagrid would not have had any cause to make special friends with Harry. Hagrid doesn't seem to have close friendships with students other than Harry and through him, Ron and Hermione. Peter Pettigrew's dramatic framing of Sirius Black had everything to do with the Marauders. If Voldemort's failed plot had taken place at the Longbottom residence, it's unclear that James and Lily Potter would ever have come into enough danger to bring Sirius fleeing to their home.

Pettigrew might well have thought the better of his traitorous plans if they weren't likely to garner approval from the Dark Lord himself. Indeed, unless Dumbledore suspected that Harry might be chosen, the Potters may not have sought a Secret Keeper at all. In any case, Sirius' long stint in Azkaban would have been avoided. Wizarding circles in Britain are not so large that Draco Malfoy would not have met Neville well before they began at school.

Adrienne is very into films and she enjoys a bit of everything: from superhero films to heartbreaking dramas, to low-budget horror films.

Every time she manages to commit to a TV show without getting bored, an angel gets its wings. When she's not writing, you can find her trying to learn a new language, watching hockey go Avs!

Weasley when Ron looks over and sees Neville accompanied by a stern-looking elderly woman, his grandmother. Ron shouts Neville's name and runs over to greet him. Neville's grandmother is shocked to learn that Neville hasn't told his friends that his parents are currently living in St. Mungo's wing long-term: "They didn't give their health and their sanity so their only son would be ashamed of them, you know!

So, the truth about Neville's parents and their torture at the hands of Bellatrix Lestrange comes out by accident. Despite the unexpected nature of this revelation, Neville does seem ready to open up about his parents' horrible assault. Like Harry, he was essentially orphaned by Voldemort, and he admires Harry's interview with The Quibbler , saying, "It must have been Finally, in the Department of Mysteries, Neville must confront his own personal demon, Bellatrix Lestrange.

As Bellatrix mocks him for what she did to his parents, Neville bravely insists that Harry absolutely cannot hand over the glass prophecy ball. Even when Bellatrix casts the Crucio curse on Neville — the same spell that drove his parents insane — he still stands strong.

Much like Harry, Neville faces the person who tore apart his family, who ruined his life, and stands strong. He was born at the end of July, his parents were decommissioned by one of Voldemort's people, he found the prophecy, and he is directly responsible for Voldemort's death and not Harry in the films.

Harry is the Chosen One since he's the one Voldemort chose. However, the prophecy could refer to both of them, I think. Being the boy who lived and being the chosen one in both the book and film is treated as two different things, yes they are related but being the boy who lived did not make Harry automatically the chosen one. So in the films, it is my opinion that Neville is still the chosen one.

No, Lily did not think "I'm going to sacrifice myself so that my son may kill Voldemort" she thought "I am going to sacrifice myself so that my son may possibly live past tonight.