Or it could be about the rise of American authoritarianism and how xenophobia and racism are just as powerful as an interdimensional alien threat at spurring people to throw away their own rights. For example, one of the recurring symbols in the book is the classic smiley face smeared with a trail of crimson blood, embedded into panels with masterful subtlety:.
In , headed into the fight to become the Republican presidential nominee, Senator Ted Cruz did a series of interviews about pop culture. One of the topics broached was his favorite comic book superheroes. Giving Cruz the benefit of the doubt, this list could easily have been the work of assistants and his PR firm to pick heroes that would make Cruz seem cool and well-read; superhero stalwarts like Iron Man and Spider-Man were also on the list. But Rorschach in Watchmen is a repugnant, egotistical nihilist, a hateful, paranoid vigilante who constantly puts himself above the law.
Given how Moore felt about Rand and Ditko and how he created Rorschach to be a vessel for these views, interpreting Rorschach to be a hero worth emulating becomes antithetical. Though you could argue that with how xenophobic and racist President Donald Trump turned out to be, maybe idolizing a Rorschach was, at the time, a clever ploy from Cruz to appeal to a like-minded, at-times-extremist voter base.
A recurring criticism within the negative reviews was that Snyder, who has a cinematic track record of eroticizing masculinity and violence and has been criticized for dabbling in racism in his movie , kind of missed the point of all the violence and the critical eye against superheroism that Moore and Gibbons baked into their comic. But the way we feel about Watchmen, any adaptation of Watchmen , and the rich world of comic books like it, are feelings sparked by our own personal values, perceived hypocrisies and injustices, and barometers of heroism.
And the magic of this book is that it allows us to tap into those feelings by losing ourselves in its story. Our mission has never been more vital than it is in this moment: to empower through understanding.
Financial contributions from our readers are a critical part of supporting our resource-intensive work and help us keep our journalism free for all. Please consider making a contribution to Vox today to help us keep our work free for all.
Cookie banner We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our site, show personalized content and targeted ads, analyze site traffic, and understand where our audiences come from. By choosing I Accept , you consent to our use of cookies and other tracking technologies.
In , Watchmen skewered the way we love superheroes. Reddit Pocket Flipboard Email. The great clown - Pagliacci - is in town. Go see him. That should pick you up. Everybody laugh. Roll on snare drum. Sign In. Play trailer Action Drama Mystery. Director Zack Snyder. Dave Gibbons based on the graphic novel co-created by David Hayter screenplay by Alex Tse screenplay by.
Top credits Director Zack Snyder. See more at IMDbPro. Trailer Watchmen: Trailer 2. Watchmen: Scream Awards Trailer. Watchmen: Trailer 1. Watchmen: Journal 4. Clip A Guide to the Films of Zack Snyder. What We Know About "Watchmen" So Far. Photos Top cast Edit. Jackie Earle Haley Rorschach as Rorschach. Billy Crudup Dr. Manhattan as Dr. Manhattan …. Matt Frewer Moloch as Moloch.
James M. Zack Snyder. More like this. Golda describes the relationship between the philosophy of determinism and Dr. Manhattan, who " lives his now-immortal life with a perception of time and events as unchangeable. He becomes the symbol of determinism " and " lives his own life under this illusion of determinism[,] failing to see that there was a superior intellect that could outsmart even an 'all knowing' being.
Manhattan — who will become a kind of God — initially grows up as a watchmaker. It is often Dr. Manhattan who discusses issues of determinism and free will, as when he explains to the second Silk Spectre, " We're all puppets, Laurie.
I'm just a puppet who can see the strings. Megalomania is also addressed in Watchmen , but not with conventional "villains". Instead, Ozymandias is presented as an idealist who looks to the past for inspiration so that he may better use his prodigious intellect to help mankind.
A final theme that is addressed throughout the novel is human morality, particularly in the contrast between absolutism, consequentialism and moral relativism, and each of the masked adventurers seems to have a different take on how to behave in this regard.
At the extreme end of absolutism is Rorschach. Rorschach is the pinnacle of this philosophy; he believes that all criminals should be punished for their crimes and often treats radically different types of criminals in very similar ways for example, he executes both a serial rapist and a common mugger. He denies the impact of culture and context on his actions a repeated mantra of his which appears several times during the book is " Not even in the face of Armageddon.
Never compromise. As Ozymandias puts it: " I believe he's a man of great integrity, but he seems to view the world in very black and white, Manichean terms.
At the other extreme in moral relativism is the Comedian. While the Comedian's own moral code is cast into severe doubt throughout the novel Doctor Manhattan describes him as "deliberately amoral", whereas Rorschach merely questions his "moral lapses" , he seems to be almost nihilistic at times. However, his tendencies are clearly demonstrated at the first meeting of the Crimebusters in , when he explains why attempting to destroy organized crime rings is of no consequence: " inside thirty years the nukes are gonna be flyin' like maybugs However, at the finale of the novel, Ozymandias' views on morality are firmly established, and seem to be justified by their outcomes: Despite requiring the murder of three million New Yorkers and a hundred or so talented artists and scientists from around the globe, the deception of the entire world, and many other highly questionable acts, he has convinced most of the other main characters to accept the outcome of his actions.
The parallel between his actions and the conclusion of the Black Freighter story serves to weaken this interpretation. In addition, the ambiguous ending, wherein the New Frontiersman may or may not publish Rorschach's journal revealing the conspiracy, leaves the reader wondering whether or not Ozymandias has actually accomplished his goal or merely postponed an inevitable Armageddon — a point reinforced by Dr.
Manhattan's enigmatic comments made before his departure. In the end, Moore leaves the morality of the characters open to reader interpretation. Penciller, inker, and letterer Dave Gibbons and colorist John Higgins are credited with giving life to the various characters in Watchmen.
They employed a variety of innovative techniques, a style that contained elements of the Golden Age of Comics and a deliberate attempt to inject realism. Gibbons, who had worked with Moore on previous occasions, including a notable Superman story Annual 11, " For the Man Who Has Everything " , avoided convention in his work and developed a storyboard-like style to present the dialogue written by Moore.
Nearly every panel includes significant details of the story-line or visual motifs such as triangles and pyramids with themes important to the plot.
Golda describes the artwork as " both a tribute to the Gold and Silver Age style[s] of super hero comics. Moreover, Watchmen rarely uses motion lines to indicate motion, another technique often utilized in the comic book industry.
In Watchmen , motion lines are only used to indicate small actions, and are not utilized in fight scenes. Instead, Gibbons uses "posture and blood" to highlight the motion and movement of the characters, which "[adds] to the feel of realism and [limits the] authorial voice". Also missing are the written, onomatopoeic sound effects that are a traditional comic book storytelling technique. Gibbons described his design of the characters as his own, derived from Moore's character notes.
Moore credits Gibbons with coming up with many of the signature symbols in Watchmen , including the iconic smiley face, which was " derived from behavioral psychology tests. They tried to find the simplest abstraction that would make a baby smile. In addition, John Higgins' coloring technique was to rely upon primary colors, again indicative of the Golden Age style, rather than a wider color selection. Gibbons, who had no formal art training, notes among his inspirations Norman Rockwell , who was sometimes described as an illustrator with an idealized portraiture style, and Jack Kirby.
The art, while deriving inspiration from various predecessors including Will Eisner and Wally Wood also named by Gibbons as major influences , is at once original in its execution and can be seen as a precursor to later realistic comic book artists such as Alex Ross.
There are many references to clocks and watches throughout the story, as Jon Osterman being trained initially as a watchmaker analogy, Janey Slater's watch which causes the test vault accident , the street watch seller who dies holding a watch showing , the many watches showing "" shortly before the "alien" teleport, the destroyed watch on the cover of Time magazine, and Veidt's mechanical model of the solar system.
Adrian Veidt's teleportation technique uses tachyons , hypothetical particles with space-like four-momentum and imaginary proper time. There are also almost as many clocks set to , a reference to the setting of the Doomsday Clock. In addition, the recurring smiley button also resembles a clock face, with the blood stain appearing as a hand on the minute position. Amid the debris on the floor in Hollis Mason 's home is a copy of the novel Gladiator by Philip Wylie, which is thought to have inspired the creation of Superman.
Kennedy was murdered. This actually happened. In the same occasion, someone comments on Washington Post journalists Woodward and Bernstein being found dead, resulting in the Watergate being violently avoided in the universe of Watchmen , where Nixon was re-elected many times over.
Kitty Genovese , whose story is told by Rorschach, was a real-life person. Interestingly, in another Alan Moore work, V for Vendetta , Stanley Milgram's infamous conformity experiments are explicitly referenced, which are considered by many psychologists to be a major influence on Darley and Latane's later experiments concerning the bystander effect which were inspired by the behavior of Kitty Genovese's neighbors witnessing her rape and murder.
Nova Express , Adrian Veidt's magazine which accuses Dr. Manhattan of causing cancer, is the title of a novel by William Burroughs. Burroughs' "cut-up" technique is mentioned by Veidt when watching multiple TV screens. A pivotal scene where Rorschach handcuffs a man to a post, gives him a hacksaw, and then burns the man to death seems to be taken directly from the Australian film Mad Max , where the hero, Max Rockatansky, does exactly the same thing in the last minutes of the film.
Watchmen was published in single-issue form over the course of and Ozymandias: Adrian Veidt was born into a wealthy family but gave up his fortune at the age of 17 to discover himself. He went to Egypt and learned of Rameses II, who became his hero. He then came to the US and started to train himself physically while also building his own fortune. She was forced into the hero business by her mother and eventually met up with the previously mentioned characters.
There she struck up a relationship with Dr. Manhattan and the two are living together. In the comics, a memory of Laurie meeting The Comedian and the ending to the book confirmed that her real father was The Comedian. Sally was almost raped by him when they first met, but at some point in the past, the two were together and she still loved him.
An aging hero known as The Comedian is killed in his apartment in A former cohort of his known as Rorschach investigates the scene and figures someone is killing costumed heroes. He goes to find other heroes he worked with: Nite Owl, Dr. Manhattan and Silk Spectre. They ultimately discover that another former teammate, Ozymandias, was behind an elaborate plot to save the world by his own terms.
He had a team of scientists create a giant squid-like creature that was transported to New York City, killing millions. His plan was that the strange monster would convince the US and Soviet Union to announce a peace treaty to fight off what would be considered aliens, thus saving the world from possible nuclear Armageddon between the two superpowers. Ozymandias had to keep his plan a secret leading him to personally kill The Comedian, who had stumbled across an island where he saw parts of the ultimate plan being worked on.
Manhattan eventually appeared, but he saw the benefits of the plan so didn't see a reason to interfere. Rorschach, with his sense of justice, wanted to tell the world of the crime but was killed by Dr. Nite Owl and Silk Spectre were at a loss over the whole ordeal and fell in love. The two went on their own to be regular civilians with new names. Manhattan left Earth permanently for Mars. Rorschach sent a written account of the whole plan to a news outlet thus ending the comic on the question of whether the public would learn the truth.
This plot summary, of course, doesn't portray the sheer amount of character development, themes and nuances Moore included in 12 issues. However, it does give a bite-size synopsis to better understand the show. Watchmen was one of those properties that always seemed impossible to make, but Zack Snyder gave it a shot in Depending on your devotion to the comic, it was either incredibly faithful or a complete hack job. The film had much of the dialogue and scenes taken directly from the comic, but there was one big change made to the ending.
Instead of a squid-like creature created and sent to New York, Ozymandias planned for several attacks across the globe to appear to have come from Dr. Snyder says the reach for this change was how long it would require to explain the plan. Because of this change, however, the movie is not canon in regards to the Watchmen TV series.
In the first episode, there was a sudden downpour of small squids that was considered more of an annoyance by the characters rather than something to be concerned about. This implies that since the squid attack of , there has been some sort of ongoing operation to fool the people into thinking squid-like aliens are still attacking the planet. HBO's Watchmen takes place in , 34 years after the squid attack, now referred to as D.
To help flesh out the Watchmen world in the comics, Moore added additional readings at the end of each comic in the form of memos, newspaper articles and book excerpts. After each episode, the website adds links to additional content to read. Some have spoilers for the previous episode. Here is a rundown of each week's extra reading material and its relevance to the show's episodes:. A memo by FBI Dep. Director Max Farragut discusses how the agent is no longer with the agency.
It seems Petey failed to follow an order to suspend his activities in Tulsa, and he's now missing, likely to continue investigating the events in the city. This memo has a few interesting points to it. First off, Petey's office was filled with comic books to which the director asked how people are obsessed with pirates. In the Watchmen universe, because there are superheroes in the world, the comics were more focused on pirates similar to how prior to the first appearance of Superman, comics in the US were all about Westerns.
Second, the director also mentions there was a jug of oil leftover, thus adding more proof that Petey was Lube Man. The final point, and the one of most interest, is that the director says Laurie Blake is being debriefed at the time of the memo. He also goes onto to shoot down rumors of a conspiracy linking President Robert Redford to the hoax created by Adrian Veidt. The director even reminds agents to remember the oaths they took.
It's clear that the US government could continue to help cover up the squid attack even with Adrian in custody. Memo: Fogdancing -- Fogdancing is a book that made multiple appearances in the show.
Written by an author named Max Shea, Fogdancing is considered a counter-culture book popular during the Nixon administration and among masked vigilantes. Petey was also a big fan and even entered a contest on what was the plot of the book, which he ended up losing.
The memo gives some subtle hints that Fogdancing is what inspired him to make his own hero persona of "Lube Man" from episode 4. One thing not mentioned in the entry is that Shea -- who also wrote the Black Freighter in the Watchmen comics -- was picked by Adrian Veidt to help come up with his world-saving plan. He, like the others who were part of the team, was killed by Adrian shortly before the attack happened. Clipping: "Nothing ever ends" December, -- Unlike previous weeks, both Peteypedia entries are directly related to each other.
This clipping is Petey's submission for the contest mentioned in the memo, and it was published in a magazine dedicated to the book called Nothing Ever Ends, named after a quote one of the characters says in the book. According to the summary, Fogdancing is about a former soldier named Howie McNulty. He was part of a group of super-soldiers called Fogdancers, but that was years ago. Howie is suffering from what appears to be post-traumatic stress disorder and took an experimental drug called Shut-Eye to help with it.
He meets up with a woman who's part of an anarchist graffiti group. As the two fall more in love, Howie wants to help take down the American empire, so so he leads a group to destroy a facility that makes Sunset Haze, the Watchmen universe's version of napalm. The group planted bombs in the facility and escaped only to find out the explosion spread out for miles, killing thousands.
Howie then finds out he was used by a wealthy industrialist, and Shut-Eye was a mind-control drug. He forms another group with his former Fogdancer partner Rawhide to take down the mastermind. They end up causing Sunset Haze to rain down on the lair, destroying it but also killing his love.
0コメント